Papa Romano’s Pizza & Mr. Pita - Auburn

Reviews

• Brenden S.

  star star star star star 13 October 2026

  I had an issue ordering on the new app.  I called the store and the owner immediately resolved it without question, pizza was delivered on time and tasted great.

• Wayne W.

  star star star star star 7 October 2026

  After speaking with my attorney it seems that I can't sue this place for making a pizza so good that I ate almost the whole damn thing and could hardly breathe for the next 2 hours from being so full. Ordered the large square Garbage Can with the intent of eating 2 pieces and then having 8 more leftover for other meals. That plan went straight to hell after the first piece. This stuff is good. Really good. So good that I was praying for death after finishing slice number 7. There are still 3 in the box and they're taunting me. They know if I eat another bite I'll pop but yet they torment me. This place serves up little slices of delicious assholes. If, like me, self control isn't something you possess, order from a less awesome place.

• Ashley B.

  star star star star star 5 October 2026

  Wow! This place is amazing! The food is always good, service is amazing and the delivery is fast! We are very particular about how we want our pizza cooked, light sauce, well done and this location always does a great job! Thank you for putting up with us LOL!

• Cyonna R.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 25 September 2026

  I used to enjoy coming here to get personal pizzas and lunch combos with my boyfriend up until they tried to accuse us of smelling like marijuana!
  We arrived on time. They told us 10 mins and when we got there told us another freaking 10 mins and we needed to be somewhere.
  When my man walked inside to go and pick up our pick-up order, and they had the door open (probably because it was a nice day) so he said it was pretty breezy in there. And ig the manager lady smelled something and proceeded to yell out to him as he was paying , "Is that you? That loud?!!" And my man was definitely shook.
  How rude. How she blamed him for the smell. He also said that same manager lady was rude to him and other employees as they were all pretty busy and strothat day so may have had a slight attitude.
  Oh also to add they messed up our customized puzza after all that shit....

• Alesha S.

  star star star star_border star_border 21 September 2026

  We got an ad for a Large pizza meal deal, so we thought we'd give Papa Romano's a try! The special right now is a large one-topping pizza (deep dish, round, or thin crust) along with your choice of cheese bread or cheese sticks and cinnamon sticks for $17.99.
  
  Financially, this was a real steal! As far as taste goes, this wasn't anything to write home about...although it's still something to write Yelp about. ;)
  
  The difference between the cheese sticks and cheese bread is that I guess the bread is more like a deep dish pizza where the sticks are thinner. They arrived and look like a sauceless cheese pizza. I'm not sure why these are not delicious, as they are sooo cheesy, but they taste like nothing! The marinara they sent along was a little bitter and pretty sweet...too much sugar!
  
  We got the standard litmus test pizza...pepperoni...and it was likewise pretty flavorless. They definitely don't skimp on the cheese, though. The crust was supposed to be flavored, but alas, it was plain.
  
  The cinnamon sticks were pretty good, but too dry! There's a wispy drizzle of icing that if it were thicker would make these cinnamon pizza crusts amazing! Please use more icing! Pretty please!
  
  Overall, this isn't the worst pizza in the world, but it's definitely not the best. Anyone wanna go to Buddy's?? :P